Why don't companies value customer loyalty?
A subject we frequently return to in this blog is the inertia trap. By this we mean the tendency to stick with a subscription, insurance policy, gym membership or other service, despite a growing feeling that we could get a better deal by taking our business elsewhere.
In business-to-business markets, this is a particularly common occurrence. You find a supplier, they meet your initial requirements and do a reasonably satisfactory, if somewhat half-hearted, job. They know, however, that you are unlikely to move your business elsewhere because doing so involves time, effort and a degree of risk. Why change something that is working well enough?
This behaviour is closely related to what psychologists call the endowment effect. We tend to place a higher value on what we already have than on an alternative we have yet to experience. The perceived costs of switching suppliers, combined with the uncertainty of dealing with someone new, can be enough to keep us where we are, even when we suspect we could do better.
In both consumer and B2B markets, banks and insurance companies are frequent beneficiaries of this phenomenon.
Let me give you a personal example.
Twenty years ago, my wife bought a Mercedes A-Class. This was the rather stubby-looking version that became famous for alarming motoring journalists during the so-called 'moose test'. The test involved a sudden swerve to avoid an imaginary moose running into the road. The original A-Class famously struggled with this manoeuvre, prompting Mercedes to make significant changes to the car's suspension and stability systems.
My wife loved the car and, when it eventually reached the end of its useful life, she wanted to replace it with something very similar.
Mercedes had moved on in its design, however, and the only way to find a comparable car was to buy a slightly newer second-hand version (see the photo). When it came to insuring the replacement, I naturally assumed that the premium would be much the same as before. The car was worth only £5,000, the drivers were unchanged and there were no other significant differences in our circumstances.

Imagine my surprise when the annual premium jumped from £350 to more than £700.
This was too large an increase to accept without question. When I phoned the insurance company to ask for an explanation, I received nothing that could reasonably be described as an answer. The premium, I was told, was simply the figure produced by their computer and its pricing algorithm.
We had been with the same insurer for twenty years and had never made a claim. Nevertheless, with considerable reluctance, we decided that we had no choice but to take our business elsewhere. After comparing prices, we managed to find cover for around £550. Better, certainly, but still considerably more than we had previously been paying.
The experience generated a surprising number of negative emotions.
First, there was bitterness and anger towards our original insurer. We had been given no satisfactory explanation for why our premium had more than doubled when so little else had changed. We were confused by the apparent lack of logic and frustrated that nobody seemed able or willing to explain the increase.
Then there was the inconvenience. We had to spend time researching alternatives, comparing policies and arranging new cover. And finally, there was uncertainty. Had we made the right choice? Would the new insurer hit us with an equally dramatic price increase next year? And, more importantly, what would it be like to deal with if we ever needed to make a claim?
What I find difficult to understand is why companies appear to place so little value on customer loyalty.
Finding a new customer in the first place is often the hardest and most expensive part of doing business. Once a customer has been acquired, surely the priority should be to retain them and develop the relationship. Companies should be thinking about customer lifetime value, net revenue retention and, just as importantly, the likelihood that a dissatisfied customer will share their experience with others and damage the company's reputation.
These are not sophisticated or unusual business considerations. They are fundamental to running a customer-oriented organisation. So why do so many companies behave as though loyal customers have little or no value?
Almost every company would claim that it values its customers. Consumer businesses might point to their loyalty schemes, through which customers accumulate points and exchange them for goods or services. B2B companies might talk about the regular customer satisfaction surveys they conduct to monitor how well they are performing.
But there is a difference between measuring customer satisfaction and making customers feel valued.
For many companies, customers are little more than numbers on a spreadsheet. If one decides to leave, so be it. Another can be found to take their place. There is little evidence of a personal relationship between customer and supplier, or any recognition that the relationship itself has value.
And herein lies what I believe is the real explanation for the lack of loyalty.
Loyalty, true loyalty, exists between people, not between people and things.
As relationships between customers and suppliers have become increasingly impersonal, particularly with the growth of digital channels and automated customer service, the human connection that encourages loyalty has been weakened or lost altogether.
So what should a genuinely customer-oriented company do about this? Here are three simple measures that cost relatively little to implement but could make a significant difference.
1. Pick up the phone.
A phone call every now and then, even just once a year, to ask how things are going would take very little time. It provides an opportunity to identify problems, understand changing needs and, most importantly, demonstrate that somebody cares about the customer.
2. Reward loyalty through pricing.
When revising prices, companies should recognise the value of an existing customer. A price that acknowledges the length and value of the relationship will be appreciated far more than an automatic increase that treats a twenty-year customer in exactly the same way as somebody who signed up yesterday.
3. Say thank you.
An email or a short personal note once a year to thank a customer for their continued business is hardly a major undertaking. Yet it reinforces an important message: we recognise your loyalty and appreciate your business.
None of these measures is particularly complicated or expensive. But they all demonstrate something that seems increasingly rare in business: an appreciation that customers are people, not just account numbers.
Companies that rely on customer inertia to retain their business may enjoy a comfortable existence for a while. But inertia is not loyalty. And when customers finally decide that enough is enough, the supplier may discover that twenty years of business can disappear in a single afternoon.



